Friday, December 16, 2011

Sustainability Action Plan

Sustainability Action Plan

For my Sustainability Action Plan I have chosen to focus on over packaging, specifically shoe over packaging.  I have chosen to address this issue because I work at Kohl’s and I see how horribly over packaged shoes are.  In doing research for this project I found a post from a consumer who is just as frustrated as I am with this issue.  Here is a copy of her post from http://www.city-data.com/forum/green-living/529779-womens-shoes-over-packaging.html.
“I'm definitely not an environmental activist type, but it really ticks me off when I shop for shoes and find all the extra packaging and trash in every box!

I'm sure many of you shop at DSW. If you don't, it's this great shoe store that has tons of designer shoes at decent prices. But this happens at every shoe store, include department stores.

This is how my typical shoe-shopping trip goes:

See a pair of shoes I like. Look through the boxes to find my size. Go to a bench to sit down. Open box. Pull aside tissue paper. Sometime shoes are individually wrapped. Remove individual wrapping. Pull out first shoe, which has a weird plastic thing in it to keep it in shape. Remove plastic thing. Remove big wad of tissue paper in the shoe. Try to put shoe on foot, but encounter another wad in the toe of the shoe. Take out foot, remove toe-wad. Try to put shoe on again, hit the little square bag of "dessicant." Throw that on the floor. Repeat whole process for other shoe.

By now, floor is covered with wads of paper, weird plastic things, dessicant packs, plastic bags, and more tissue paper. Whether or not I buy the shoes, I sure as heck ain't putting that mess back together. Besides the store has one trash can like 100 yards away. After a few customers trying on a few pairs of shoes each, the place is covered in trash.

I've complained to the people who work there (it's at every shoes store, not just DSW). They say they hate it too, but it's the manufacturer who is responsible. It's so wasteful! Even if all the tissue paper is biodegradable, I'm sure the plastic stuff isn't. And why so much of it? It seems that they had to hire a swarm of people just to do all this packaging, which I'm sure jacks up the price of the shoes too.

What can you do? I'm sure the factories in the Taiwan-indo-pines don't give a damn about our issues with over packaging. I've considered putting all the garbage into a box and mailing it to them.

I mean, we can't just stop buying shoes, right? And I'm definitely not the thrift store/used Birkenstock type so please don't go there.

I guess I'm partly looking for suggestions, but mostly just wanted to rant and see whether this bothers other people too.”

San Diego has a program where they encourage people to reduce waste and this is from their website. http://www.sandiego.gov/environmental-services/recycling/consumer.shtml#avoid

“Reduce Packaging

Approximately one-third of the garbage we generate is packaging that is thrown away immediately after we purchase merchandise. While it's true that some packaging is necessary for health, safety, shelf-life and theft considerations, many manufacturers over-package their products. This excess packaging costs consumers more money; costs our environment more resources and energy; and uses valuable landfill space.
So take a little extra care before you buy. Look for an alternative product without packaging or the least amount of packaging to send a message to manufacturers that you don't like waste. Also, avoid single-serving items that are overly packaged. Ask local vendors to avoid using excessive packaging.”
In the UK there is this website http://www.overpackaging.com/Pictures.htm#captial%20one that encourages consumers to get involved by bring over packagers to our attention and then bringing it their attention that we are unhappy with their over packaging.  I like their model and this is the method I have chosen to use to try and help with over packaging in the US and specifically with shoes.
I intend to take a camera into work and take pictures of shoes in their boxes as they come from the manufacturer. All of the shoe brands that Kohl’s sells have massive over packaging, there is not one brand that seems to be trying to reduce packaging; most of the interior packaging is wasteful and useless.
I will then post the pictures to website that I will set up and contact the manufacturers and tell them that I and many others are unhappy with their over packaging and ask them to explain the reason behind it. I will also contact The Environmental Defense Fund who I have already contacted about this issue.  This is what I received from them in response to my email.
Hello, Julie, and thank you for reaching out! This is the type of work our corporate partnerships program works on every day. EDF is an innovator in the environmental field for working with companies to mitigate their environmental impact. We’ve done big, iconic projects with McDonalds, FedEx, and now Walmart, and many companies in between. We’re also doing great work with our Climate Corps Fellowship program – we place MBA students with a company for a summer to evaluate their environmental impact and how it can save money (hint: being green saves!) I suggest you learn more about that work at business.edf.org Now, your problem – this is complicated! Environmental change often requires big systemic changes, but it’s even more complicated for a store like yours that relies on so many different suppliers – Kohl’s does not create its own shoes, but purchases shoes from different companies. That’s why I think you would be really interested in our work with Wal-Mart. Walmart is similar to Kohls in that they pull from many different distributors, and they have made great strides in this work as a partner with EDF. We even have an office in Bentonville, Arkansas – right by their headquarters – just to work with them. The fact is, environmentally friendly policies will save companies money. That’s what we’ve seen with all our partners. These companies are not making the decision to change their supply chain out of the goodness of their heart. They are making these decisions because they will save them money. That’s when it gets really exciting. Now, how to approach your problem, I am unsure. I suggest you review the literature on our site and elsewhere and see what you can learn and how it applies to your work. Then, if Kohl’s has some type of employee feedback line, take your cause there. Finally (and I’m saying this not just as an employee at EDF but also as a huge fan of the program!) consider suggesting taking on a Climate Corps fellow next year (and learn more about the program here: http://business.edf.org/projects/edf-climate-corps) Thank you for reaching out to us, and please be in touch if I can assist you further. Best wishes, Kathryn
Kathryn Chiasson
Member Services Associate

Environmental Defense Fund
1875 Connecticut Avenue NW
Washington, DC 20009
T 202 572 3391
kchiasson@edf.org
edf.org

I like her idea of have a Climate Corp fellow join Kohl’s.  There are many areas where Kohl’s could do better at reducing waste. Kohl’s prides themselves on being a green company and I think they would welcome the positive publicity as well as the financial savings a program like this could make. 
My approach then would be a two pronged one. One, I would create negative publicity for the shoe manufacturers themselves via the internet, by exposing the amount of wasteful over packaging they are producing. Two, I would work with Kohl’s directly to see if I can effect change from within the company by getting them to see how much money and time (and therefore more money) is wasted because of over packaging.  With the help of the internet and The Environmental Defense Fund I hope that I could change this situation into a much less wasteful and more sustainable one.






No comments:

Post a Comment